Top Menu

Message in a bottle, re: KPFA’s cancellation of Richard Dawkins

Dawkins poster KPFAI had a feeling that this brouhaha over Richard Dawkins at KPFA would happen. My involvement with the station these days is pretty minimal, but a couple of Sundays ago I dropped by as a guest on my friend Sherry Gendelman’s wonderful classical music show Piano. As we entered the Berkeley, California signal’s building entrance, I saw the poster for Dawkins’ appearance.

“Wow,” I thought to myself. “Richard Dawkins on KPFA. Really?” Ten days later the speaking event cancellation made The New York Times, answering my question.  “Well, yeah, not really,” I responded to the initially surprised me.

KPFA says that it cancelled Richard Dawkins after discovering his Islamophobic comments. To be fair, Dawkins insists that he is not an Islamophobe; we’ll get to that later. But I don’t think that’s the deeper reason why the Dawkins talk was scotched. I think that the cancellation happened because KFPA runs on a revenue/speech model that limits the possibility of Dawkins or anyone like him from speaking.

Before we get to that, I suppose I should say that I’ve never been much of a Dawkins fan. I read The Selfish Gene as a nicely couched exercise in biological determinism. I view his atheism as just another blend of fundamentalism. As for Dawkins himself, I experience him as Bill Maher without the jokes.

And I thought all this even before he jumped on the Islam-Is-Bad-Bad-Bad bandwagon. In 2013 Dawkins famously tweeted that “Islam is the greatest force for evil in the world today. I’ve said so, often and loudly.” Since then his defenders have said that the comment was taken out of context. But that’s almost a tautology. Everything on Twitter is out of context. Free advice: if you want to say something in context, don’t say it on Twitter. In any event, subsequent Dawkins walk back comments have emphasized that “Individual Muslims suffer more from Islam than anyone else” (um, perhaps more than a few disagree given that they are still Muslims?) and of course Dawkins has condemned Trump’s travel ban. The problem is that the political impetus for the ban was surely bolstered by comments like, well, “Islam is the greatest force for evil in the world today.”   

Having said all this, I still think it would have been fine, even fun, for Dawkins to appear on KPFA (he has done KPFA events before). The problem is that the KPFA on which Dawkins could flog his latest book, even after his comments were discovered, does not exist. KPFA’s founder Lewis Hill tried to make it exist in the 1950s. He envisioned a radio station that encouraged radical dialogue, a venue where he and his fellow pacifists and anarchists would invite the world in to answer their questions. Everybody would have a say, from communists to Daughters of the American Revolution. But the questions would come from Hill and his circle of World War II era conscientious objectors.  KPFA’s politics, then, would manifest itself not by restricting the range of participants, but by curating the questions that they had to address.

Alas, Lewis Hill quickly discovered that this kind of ambitious goal costs money, which his station did not have. Then as McCarthyism cast its long, polarizing shadow and Hill’s health deteriorated, he took his own life. The inheritors of his legacy now settled for a different project: KPFA and the Pacifica Foundation’s four other radio signals would broadcast “dissent,” the voices of the American left excluded from the rest of media. As the philosophy of “community radio” emerged in the 1970s, various identities queued up to be added to the list of marginalized voices. Today this strategy persists as a kind of palimpsest, a hodgepodge of broadcasting traditions, each written over the prior. But the end result is pretty consistent: when KPFA hosts an event, it always functions as an implicit endorsement of the event guest.

In this context, the Dawkins talk was a dead duck. KPFA simply cannot sustain a marathon premium program or event speaker who is not beloved to the station’s followers, or at least a critical mass of them.  KPFA streams to a small, passionate audience of people who pay the operation money to be told what they already think is true, to be reassured rather than challenged. Sometimes this praxis runs into trouble when the latest proprietors can’t agree on the current party line. And sometimes the norm is pleasantly broken on the station’s regular non-fundraising schedule, but the exceptions  invariably prove the rule.

Why I am writing this? Not because I think that my words will provide some impetus for KPFA to change. America’s longest running listener supported radio station has many virtues, but I’ve given up on all that. No, I just want to say that I hope that someday, someone, somewhere, will take up Hill’s mission again, his mission of radical dialogue, and create a radio station whose audience will be willing, even happy, to come to listen to Richard Dawkins speak and then ask the great man why he would say such dumbass things on Twitter.

This essay was edited on July 27.

Just one dollar a month makes you a patron of Radio Survivor. Help us through our Patreon Campaign!


, , ,

One Response to Message in a bottle, re: KPFA’s cancellation of Richard Dawkins

  1. Anjilo smith July 29, 2017 at 4:37 am #

    Post Awaiting Approval by Forum Administrator

  2. Jay332843867 August 23, 2017 at 12:45 am #

    k, the scientist Ed Stone said: This opened a historic exploration, meaning the equivalent of the first time around Shoes Outlet the human flight, the first landing on the moon. Ancient song ‘flowing water’ met with the sound If the earth civilization and even the solar system is destroyed by an unknown reason, what can prove that human beings have existed and created such a glorious history of civilization Lesbian Ann Arruyan Ann Druyan may have never thought that such a question of eternity, even brought her love, this love witness also by ‘Traveler No. 1’ and ‘Traveler No. 2’ belt To the outer space, sent to the possible existence of aliens. The later became her husband is the success of the planet astronomer, science writer and NASA NASA scientific adviser Carl Sagan Carl Sagan. Sarken is a descendant of Russian Jewish immigrants in New York, although his parents have no culture, but very much attention to the child’s education, so that he has a good scientific literacy. In 1939, his parents visited the New York World Exposition with a 5-year-old Sagan. At the World Expo, he witnessed the ‘Westinghouse Capsule’ Westinghouse Time Capsule’s burial ceremony. This capsule and the ‘Time Capsule 2’ planted in 1964 Michael Kors Backpacks and Luggage will be opened in 6939. Karl Sagan from the beginning to participate in the US space program. Since the 1950s, he has become a NASA scientific adviser. In addition to preparing the experimental project for the Moon and Solar Spacecraft, Sagan also loaded its own ‘time capsule’ on the spacecraft, the launch of the spacecraft pioneer No. 10 in 1972, and the 11th launched in 1973, System of gold-plated nameplate, engraved above the human image and the earth’s position in the universe. In 1977, NASA’s ‘Traveler Project’ personnel department asked Sagan to ‘prepare some information for alien civilizations that might be encountered.’ Sagan convened a small committee to prepare for ‘first contact’. ‘When Karl first made the project to me and Tim Felice, it felt like a myth.’ The popular information recording technology of the 1970s was an 8-track tape. This is not a good choice, because the tape is easy to degrade, especially from the space of radiation and magnetic field will quickly digest the information on the tape. Frank Drake, a radio astronomer who devoted his life to finding alien civilization signals, made a metal record, because the record of this ancient technology is very likely to be understood and interpreted by aliens. As long as appropriate shielding, etching information on metal records can be stored for millions of years. At a meeting of the table, the committee finally decided to choose 90 minutes of music and 100 or so photos, as the first contact with alien civilization witness. In terms of language Cheap Crossbody Bags greetings, Sarken turned to the Department of Foreign Languages ​​at Cornell University and collected greetings from the oldest Sumerian language to a total of 55 languages ​​spoken by a 5-year-old American child. In the Western music, Beethoven’s ‘Fifth Symphony’ fate, Chuck Berry’s rock ‘Johnny B · Goode’ selected, the Beatles although very much hope that the ‘sun came out’ sent to space But because the band did not have the Nike Free TR Fit copyright of the song. Chinese music, as creative director of the security • De Lu Yan after hard search, found the spread of 2,500 years of ancient music ‘water’ player is the Chinese guqin performer Guan Pinghu, excitement, she called to Sagin this report News, because Sagan is not, she left in the answering machine. Previously they were just working on acquaintances and friends, nothing more. An hour later, Sagan returned to the phone, at the end of the call, he proposed to the proposed marriage, security should be. Ann said: Nike Air Max Womens ‘I put a phone call, screamed and jumped up.’ This is June 1, 1977. Immersed in love sweet in the security and put forward a new idea, recorded a brain wave of audio files on the album, be regarded as the future of advanced alien civilization out of a question to see if they can break brain waves in the idea The The proposal was deeply rooted by Sagan and other members, who encouraged the recording of their own. So the 27-year-old young woman’s brain waves with the United Nations Secretary-General and the US President’s greetings, whale Nike Air Max Shoes Outlet and dog calls and 116 photos, 90 minutes of music in more than two months after the traveler No. 1, No. 2 Into space. Karl Sagan presided over the design of the ‘gold record’ to become the history of human alien exchange important ‘time capsule’, which was collected by him as ‘Earth Voice’ Murmurs of Earth. In later days, Ann Arunyan and Karl Sagan co-authored the most popular popular science film ‘universe’ in history, co-wrote several popular science Cheap Coach Bags books. They married in 1981, accompanied by life, until 1996, Carl died. ‘Sailor’ upgrade to ‘navigator’ The birth of the traveler project can be described as heavenly, geography, and. The 1977 United States has been ahead of the Cold War opponents of the Soviet Union in the space race. 20 years ago, on October 4, 1957, the Soviet Union was shocked to launch the first human satellit

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes