Top Menu

NPR, professor have he said/she said over “he said/she said” abortion story

Welcome to Kansas.NPR is not taking scholar Jay Rosen’s charge that the network has engaged in one of the “lowest forms of journalism” lying down.

“Rosen is a journalism professor whose provocative positions on media responsibility and new media have often succeeded in shaking up a sometimes hidebound profession,” notes NPR Ombudsman Edward Schumacher-Matos. “But this time he overstates his case.”

The alleged he/she-said in question comes in the form of a report on anti-abortion group efforts to create tougher state requirements for abortion clinic licenses in Kansas. These rules involve setting standards for the temperature and size of procedure rooms. Rosen apparently felt that the neutrality of NPR reporter Kathy Lohr, who covered a hearing on the issue, amounted to a case of reality avoidance.

“The new Kansas regulations may be a form of harassment, intended to make life as difficult as possible for abortion providers in that state,” Rosen contended in a protest to Schumacher-Matos himself. “Or, alternatively, these rules may be sane, rational, common sense, sound policy: just normal rule-making by responsible public officials.”

But:

According to this report, NPR has no idea who is right. It cannot provide listeners with any help in sorting through such a dramatic conflict in truth claims. It knows of no way to adjudicate these clashing views. It is simply confused and helpless and the best it can do is pass on that helplessness to listeners of “Morning Edition.”

Rosen’s bottom line:

This is he said, she said  reporting, one of the lowest forms of journalism in existence, in which the NPR reporter washes her hands of determining what is true.

NPR’s Schumacher-Matos defends the story—arguing that it did acknowledge the political nature of the debate. But then he suggests that more may be needed:

I would like to see NPR directly tackle the claims of operating room safety, instead of leaving the matter only to the courts. Such claims are apparently hard to measure, even though the Kansas abortion opponents say they have 2,500 pages of documentation supporting their claims. But the proponents of the regulations make no secret that they are pursing a harassment strategy up to the legal limit. As Lohr reported, anti-abortion rights activists in other states are trying to copy the Kansas tactic.

Rosen’s reaction to the NPR post? “ANOTHER UPDATE: The NPR ombudsman did look into it! He thinks I’m wrong. Sort of.”


Just one dollar a month makes you a patron of Radio Survivor. Help us through our Patreon Campaign!


LinkedInRedditTumblrPinterestInstapaperGoogle GmailShare

, ,

4 Responses to NPR, professor have he said/she said over “he said/she said” abortion story

  1. Trudy W Schuett September 15, 2011 at 4:56 am #

    It’s always seemed to me it’s the journalist’s job to report the facts– otherwise known as “maintaining objectivity.”

    Isn’t it up to the listener to draw their own conclusions?

    Deciding for the listener what those conclusions should be is otherwise known as bias, and presumes the reporter is somehow “smarter” than the average listener.

    Jay Rosen is way out of line on this one. One has to ask if the subject had been something else, if he’d be so willing to criticize…

  2. Kevin McKinney September 15, 2011 at 8:10 am #

    If the facts that one side gives are lies. And the facts that the other side are also lies. And the journalist gives us the “objective view” of both sides; then the listener is left in the dark. A journalist should ask questions that reveal the truth.

  3. Keith Seraphin September 16, 2011 at 5:34 pm #

    Jay is 110% right – NPR is ducking reporting in order to go along to get along. A smokescreen to hide NPR’s institutional cowardice.

    We know that Kansas is trying to eliminate abortion clinics. The politicians there have said so. If you have no stomach to report the truth you have no business calling what you do news any more than Fox.

    When you consistently state that reporting the truth entails picking a side then clearly one side is telling lies.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes